Is eating meat wrong reddit. But tbh, men exploit everything.

Is eating meat wrong reddit if you look back at the Revolt of 1857 one of the causes was the Hindu soldiers being upset because the gun cartridges they had to tear open with their mouth were coated in cow fat. (3) One should not eat meat. Saying “eating dog is bad because me like dog” is very different. Beef eating is considered to be great sin, cows have been an integral part of Hindu society, Ma Saraswati is seen as Kamdehnu, the cow who fulfills all desires, Mahadev's vahana is Nandi, a bull, Shri Krishna was a cowherd as well, in an agrarian society like Bharat, cows have always been a boon to the farmer and pastorist households, it is from cow we attain so many of the Yeah people who think eating beef as achievement are just very cringe and they want to get attention that’s all, but people who are into food in general and find it good I don’t mind but people who boast about eating beef is real attention seeking rakhi savanth type people😅sorry again I eat a plant based diet. we had a group of Tibetan Monks visit our temple last year and I was surprised to learn that they do eat meat but that they prefer to eat beef because the taking of one life can feed many people, whereas shrimp for example would I can eat it if I want to, and my moral qualms about it do not exist. Bali is always offered to Kali, never to Gauri. Honestly the fact someone is farming them with the express purpose of eating lion rather than saving the species is well I’m not surprised it’s happening in the states. As a Those things, combined with the inherent violence to meat consumption, the political gender divide and the perception that people on the left are more likely to care about animals or the environment, has led to a lot of conservative men thinking of meat,. If we didn’t consider incest wrong, our species wouldn’t have thrived—therefore it makes sense we consider it wrong. You don't have to jump straight to eating meat with every meal - you may actually find that one meal containing meat per week is enough to satisfy your cravings. To produce one kilogram of beef requires 25 kilograms of grain – to feed the animal – and roughly 15,000 litres of water. But still, it's higher than if you cook it. increase in GHG emissions). They dig burrows in the ground. EDIT: Eating a shit tonne of meat obviously isn’t healthy - but there’s also a fair few doctors and nutritionists who agree a fair few vegans don’t receive all essential nutrients etc. Then I guess I'm not really sure what you mean by "Unless there's something wrong with meat eating, it's not clear that it's a moral question at all". Vegans often cite animal cruelty and human exploitation/ oppression of animals as a reason why it's wrong because we're using animals for our selfish ends, but isn't it just Meat eaters often argue that while meat may not be technically necessary to survive, its necessary for humans to thrive because of its caloric and nutritional density, among other Conversations regarding the ethics of eating meat are focused on whether or not it is moral to eat non-human animals. I've always been confused as to how eating meat is somehow a "manly" act. Pork is a little Since animals lack moral status, it is not wrong to eat meat, even if this is not essential to nutrition. VCJC stands as Reddit's hub for true vegans who perceive what others do not. eating meat is normal behavior for many animal species, including the great apes, and i am nothing more than a particularly intelligent and capable ape. Note: I do not believe that meat-eaters are immoral people because they've been taught to eat meat since birth and they often don't know any better. Same reason why plenty of meat eaters reject foie gras, and plenty of leather-wearers Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. Jataka 1)Bhallatiya Jataka - The Bodhisattva himself as King goes hunting for pork and venison 2) Vessantara Jataka - as prince eats meat 3) Mahasutosoma Jataka - tells a reformed prince he could return to enjoying meat. As much as possible I source it locally from farms I know treat their animals well. As it says in Romans 14:2-4: “One man has faith to eat everything, but the man who is weak [in his conscience] eats only vegetables. Some people find it disturbing to eat the meat of animals they consider pets. My son explains that he just doesn't want to eat something that had a 'face'. so most Hindu scripture promotes a vegetarian diet and cows are a sacred animal, so eating their meat is typically considered a sin. " So then I say that to me personally it is not morally wrong to eat meat. I think the reason I pointed out the pets, was to guide the usual empathetic person to the logical next step, which is like you said there is Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Given that you acknowledge that you're not a nutritionist, that a vegan diet can work for people, that eating some meat isn't ethically wrong so long as it's raised and processed humanely it seems like your opinion is less "Eating Meat is necessary" but rather "Eating Meat works for my life and I'm ok with it morally so long as it's ethically sourced" Eating meat hampers your ability to develop the Great Compassion necessary for the Bodhisattva path, it's hard to reconcile striving to save all sentient beings and eating their bodies. When I'm with my family I can't not eat meat, but when I'm alone I rarely eat red meat, I There are some people here who eat their beef raw. Eating some meat is natural for our bodies as omnivores (doesn't mean its NECESSARY, which is my actual argument not whether or not we can do it), but now when many people don't have to expel as many calories to survive or get food, when we eat meat that has been modified and/or cooked in ways that break down the nutritional value, and without a better balance of high fiber Eating pork (a massively produced meat) does make someone a hypocrite when they say we shouldn’t be eating the meat of a threatened animal species. Ultimately, this is a debate that has been ongoing for millennia, and it remains one of the most prominent topics in food ethics. My parents used to let me eat my food first before they put any kind of meat on the table. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Now onto the environmental effects: eating meat itself doesn't make that big of an effect, farming is. In the Pali suttas the Buddha does not prohibit meat eating even for monastics. So I'm like how can your culture have bred these dogs as pets, and treat them with affection, and then eat others?. Yes, eating fish is morally wrong. Humans eating meat (apart from stuff like bugs, which pretty much all mammals eat, including those we call herbivores) is a rather recent development in our evolution, and we haven't really developed into it that much, that's why so many diseases are caused by just pure natural meat, while diseases from plants are mostly only caused if they're highly processed in specific ways. I think it is a part of life, like breathing and drinking water. So, Shaivism is not as comfortable with meat eating and violence as Shaktism but it is much more accepting of I saw my mom pan fry a steak for 2 hours because my dad was caught up with something, she just lowered the temp and left it. Gaming "The individual and society as a whole. In the thread i noticed that the discussion largely focussed on the question whether eating meat is bad, while the bestiality was obviously considered bad because of the problem of consent. Yes, to me your pleasure shouldn't really be an issue. It’s dishonest to say meat is exclusively eaten for pleasure because you can get the same nutrition somewhere else. You need to raise a pig, a sheep, or a cow, kill it, feed it to the dog, then kill the dog to eat the meat. It's a struggle to even eat encourage them out of the coop or walk for any length of time, let alone act like a normal pullet. Ranching is. Even if you are not killing a plant , eating the extracts or fruits , flowers , seeds etc you are consuming the future generation of the plant just like eating egg . Their argument for eating meat is that the human body needs meat to be healthy -which it's true-, but they then proceede to eat fast food and generally unhealthy food. They eat ALL the greens, garden weeds, & treats. (This isnt even that true, dog meat is eaten everywhere dog meat is only eaten normaly in china in small villages) That compounded with the fact that animals have value and we do have empathy for them makes it wrong to eat meat. For example, I could gain pleasure from killing toddlers, but no matter how much I enjoyed this activity, it would still be wrong. It would also be a good option for someone who wants to feed their cat homemade pet food. So those particular actions probably wouldn't Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. But tbh, men exploit everything. Considering incest wrong is a trait that has helped our species thrive. However, you define your Carnivore Diet is fine by me. Eating meat in itself isn’t wrong. This is definitely true for me, even if I still eat meat out of habit and laziness. People aren’t going to eat the same thing like chicken and beef. In general it is advised to avoid having meat specifically killed for you. Or horse meat. However, I think that food waste is a major issue and if someone was going to eat meat anyway, sourcing meat that would otherwise be trashed is more ethical and sustainable than directly contributing to demand. I'd bet that eating meat is a big part of why so many of us are so messed up emotionally. 20 votes, 23 comments. That said this is not a Keto group. These meat birds are over 10 pounds at slaughter. This argument does not assume animals have any rights. For this reason, it is in general not advisable to eat carnivore animals (which is actually a problem with eating fish, because quite a lot of bigger fish live on a diet of smaller fish). I am just making the argument that the action itself is immoral. 21 It is better not to eat meat or drink wine or to do anything else that will cause your brother or sister to fall. But you definitely wouldn't eat animal meat that isn't acceptable, such as cat or dog, as that would be considered morally wrong. About me, when I was 100% vegetarian, I still ate eggs & fish and drank milk, but ate no chicken, pork or beef. People have different cultures. But within the Pali canon, the Buddha's position is consistent. When I eat meat or protein I feel better, however, morally I have felt bad about it. Then it takes 10 pounds of cow to make 1 pound of When you eat a human, you get all the mercury it has eaten in its lifetime. BUT I The commercial meat industry is not known for compassion toward animals or for the environment, and you may not want to contribute. For example, I have a basic understanding of the ethical objections to eating meat and I also understand some of the agricultural implications for sustaining/increasing global meat consumption (e. It is straight up Hi, I want to form a balanced opinion about the pro's and con's of eating meat. My dad ate it. I never ate any kind of meat. I can't imagine why I Love, is beyond painful in the list of emotions I’ve tried to eat away in my life, and as a no-red meat eater, I promise you I know from experience, eating something that can care about you is wrong. A place for open discussion about veganism and vegan issues, focusing on intellectual debate about As long as there is nutritional value in something that is part of the reason it is being eaten. I'm not assuming the animal has a right to life. The phrase eating meat means nothing more than eating meat. There are many ways we can frame the exploitation of I don’t eat meat because I realized that animals are sentient. It's natural for humans to eat meat; morally attacking people for doing so is wrong . Cholera is natural, yet most humans are more or less against it. "I’m wondering if why it’s morally ok for me to eat beef and pork" It isn't. No need to eat lamb even if a vegetarian diet was insufficient. As for using fire, given that omnivore animals like chimpanzees and bears eat animals without cooking, it seems reasonable to assume that humans discovered meat way before they discovered fire. And arguments for the permissibility of eating meat might address the reasons that vegetarians give for abstaining from eating meat. This is a meat-based group, you should have the opinion that all your nutritional needs can be met by eating meat. Cattle don't spend time with people and they don't bond with us, they don't trust us or love us. Eating meat is a completely natural thing to do - veganism isn’t. He's just Are you saying that eating does is the same as eating cows or are you saying that eating dogs is okay. Eating meat is not inherently wrong. You are feeding it meat to make meat. Which is fine, they can do whatever they want. Although they might choose not to eat some things if they know what they are. I don't understand why it's "wrong" for me to eat it. Meat substitutes are definitely an option too, although the price can vary based on the store you get them at and the country/region you live in. The argument that we evolved eating meat is extremely flawed. It makes no sense on an economic level. They run free and hop and do binkies. Like saying incest is wrong because it’s rooted in biology—that makes sense. I think most people (like me) just really like the taste of meat and try to justify it retroactively. That is where the negative association with eating meat comes from. But you aren't eating meat for survival, and you aren't eating meat of an animal that already passed away (roadkill for instance). is a bit more problematic than promoting veganism on reddit Completely disregarding morality - I find the idea nasty, and I think people who eat dogs are morons. There’s nothing wrong with meat, and whether or not we can get all our essential nutrients from plants (I heard somewhere all you need is potatoes and butter so I get that it’s possible not to eat meat) were still supposed to eat meat. It is okay to eat meat as a necessity I may eat goat but not cow and say no I wouldn’t eat dog meat and think it’s wrong. And put a regular person and a criminal in the middle of a group of hungry lions, Highly processed soy meats can be contentious in terms of health benefits. Or check it out in the app stores Home; Popular; TOPICS. Animal factories is. But if you eat meat, don't get mad if someone likes dog meat lol. Lol, the first link you posted literally says that people who eat more meat eat more calories in general, which supports what I was saying, and the third one says that all meats can help you lose weight, but chicken and fish are better than red meat because it Just think of how hard it would be to hunt enough meat for your whole family with extremely primitive clothing and equipment. If you look at primitive human societies, it also seems that we're 'built' to engage in endemic warfare, raid our neighbors for food and women, kill each other over hunting grounds and the like, but those things aren't justifiable. As far as whether it is a sin, different Hindu groups will give different answers. I've eaten pink chicken thighs, no We are built to eat meat, meat is delicious, pretty much everything on this planet is eating something else, so not sure what could possibly be wrong with it. So there's probably nothing wrong with eating a quarter pound of sausage for dinner a couple of times a week, as long as other times you consume protein from chicken, eggs, dairy, legumes, etc. I think there are right and wrong ways to eat meat. Perhaps it served a purpose then, but if that thing (i. I am privileged enough to be able to choose a vegetarian diet, so I do. The virtuous solution would be to change how we treat pigs and cows, not to start eating dogs as well. Yes, and we can eat chicken, pork and beef. In my opinion, the only situation where you are allowed to complain is if you are talking about eating animal meat in general. We eat less meat than we used to, specifically because my adult son (who lives with us) is a vegetarian. Someone might be a hunter and shoot a deer in an instant without causing pain. Top Posts Reddit . Of course, there are many reasons to think eating meat is a moral question, as Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. But if you enjoy eating a good steak, then it is hypocritical to criticize others for eating what they consider is "just The "we evolved to eat meat" argument. Locked post. Whether this is the case - ☐ Reddit is very liberal ☐ Fat children are child abuse ☐ I like Trump ☐ I don't like [women|a minority], or I wouldn't say that there's "nothing" wrong with eating dog-meat, but then again I believe that eating meat in general is kinda wrong. Cooking meat causes a chemical reaction called the Maillard reaction (or browning reaction) along with carmelization which occurs at temperatures over 140 Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app I was violently sick after eating meat and I'm unsure if it was the meat itself or something wrong with the meat that made me I haven't craved or eaten meat in my 3 years of being a veggie and it was really easy for me to convert so the whole situation was a bit Is eating meat wrong in your opinion? Archived post. If you don't want to eat dogs, then don't. We can say the same thing about other foods. If rape is not okay because it is natural (which it obviously isn't), this argument should not apply to eating meat. Then they It is natural for us to eat meat, we have done it for all of human history Reponse: We have murdered, raped, waged wars, stolen and many more things we today do not find morally permissible. Turns out, pigs It's often claimed to be a personal decision wether to eat meat or not, that shouldn't be forced onto anyone. I didn't eat the chicken as I had seasoned a different chicken drumstick and thigh for myself. I decided to have that chicken for my breakfast. If the goal is for less people to eat meat, activists will probably be more successful in arguing that eating meat is Eating meat itself is not wrong, however the act of murdering animals in order to please your desire for tasty food could be considered morally wrong. Noone ever could force me to eat any meat. While they often contain more fibre compared to meat, they also have a higher sugar content. Subjecting animals to cruelty and needless suffering before they become food is arguably wrong. All of this is not to mention the environmental, economic, and health effects of eating meat. Something being natural, however, does not make it good. It takes about 15-16 pounds of grain to produce one pound of beef, so many more plants are being killed for your meat than a vegetarian would eat. In other words, it is easy to justify "not eating dogs". You don't raise carnivores for food. Also I don’t eat meat everyday, we often have vegetarian dishes and many of those end up being vegan. I also believe that it's thoroughly hypocritical to keep a vegetarian or vegan diet while also using rendered animal products in shampoos, soaps, dyes, flavor chemicals, etc. When I say "eat "meat" I am referring to how most people get their meat. Veganism: A philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of animals, humans and the environment. Some have moral arguments for why it treats the environment, animals, and humans better. A place for open discussion about veganism and vegan issues, focusing on intellectual debate about animal rights and welfare, health, the environment, nutrition, philosophy or any Dogs are meat eaters, so if you eat a dog you're eating something that has eaten dozens of other animals in its lifetime. folks also complain about feeling crappy when going without meat when So far I have decided to only eat meat about once a day and only in very small quantities. Of course that's morally sound. It's bad to eat things that are too much like you, because you're more likely to get parasites that can infect both species. A place for open discussion about veganism and vegan issues, focusing on Also, when you are filling up on meat, you are missing out on healthy fiber. But beyond that, even if you do accept that ending animal husbandry is for the best, there are ways to eat meat that don’t kill more animals than veggies. Like just because someone eats dog meat doesn’t mean you get to have an opinion. You may be running into conflicts between different groups of texts. No wonder. As you go up in the food chain energy is wasted. The meat industry is a problem though. We try to pasture raise them, but all they want to do is sit and eat. The phrase eating meat can be associated with either ethical or unethical practices on obtaining that meat. I think the reason why (some) meat eaters reject veal is just because of the stigma attached to it. Do not by your eating destroy someone for whom Christ died. You are indicating that eating meat refers to eating unethically obtained meat. Or whatever. Unless there's something wrong with meat eating, it's not clear that it's a moral question at all. I mean, even the Dalai Lama, who says vegetarianism is preferable, eats meat twice a week. Let the one eating not look down on the one not eating, and let the one not eating not judge the one eating, for God has welcomed him. Perhaps meat form diseased cows, or cows treated with unapproved hormones. the Maasai in Kenya) Yeah, because throughout human history - and even in those cultures - dogs have been companion animals. Their consumption of Eating meat is not intrinsically wrong. There’s no reason for me to judge. it takes 10 pounds of grain to make 1 pound of cow meat. When I stopped eating meat for awhile I didn't really notice any difference, but when I ate meat again after not doing so for a bit I IMMEDIATELY felt awful. Do whatever is right for your body and your health. I feel the first time around I didn't go about it the being veg and/or vegan is a science. I don’t look down on meat eaters or think it’s wrong, I just make the decision to not do it myself. Dude, this is guy is eating out every single night. This is a lie as celery is added specifically because it is high in nitrates and serves the exact same purpose and has This group is for sharing Carnivore Diet success stories and providing positive news and information regarding Carnivory. Non-intensive animal rearing also isn't that bad environmentally as ruminants (cows, sheep etc. Not eating meat -- because it's really disturbing to kill another animal and then eat the flesh off its corpse Just because you think something is immoral doesn't mean it is. Something having philosophical significance for a person (meaning) is what underpins all choices that one makes. We've been cooking our meat for nearly half a million years. Actually,scientists are already able to create meat by multiplying animal cells so in the near future we may be able to enjoy BBQ without murdering animals. At the same time, a lot of it is cultural taboos, because I had potbellied pigs as pets and yet have never had an issue with eating pork. Meats are often eaten with unhealthy carbs. New comments cannot be posted. 20 Do not destroy the work of God for the sake of food. ) . Some of those reasons are dogs eat a lot of meat. My parents think it's "not right" that I eat it as t's for dinner. "For" is a preposition that is used to indicate the basis of an action, not its result. The reason eating people (at least without their consent) should be viewed as socially unacceptable (which is all so called immoral actions are, there is no such thing as moral or immoral according to any objective criteria), is that i have no interest in being eaten or seing my loved ones being eaten, and i have no interest in eating other people. I agree on the "meat is meat" philosophy, and if horses and dogs were raised as cattle are I would have less of a problem with it. Violence is part of nature. You can eat raw beef, but you'd better not fucking eat raw pork. But eating meat is something I think Humans have been doing for a millennia. There is an argument to be made about not eating meat at all, but that's a different discussion all together. especially red meat which is the least healthy and the worst for the environment, as a fundamental part of masculine I would not eat it. My mood dropped instantly and I felt depressed and anxious. It's true there are other options but, just like every other living thing on the planet, we choose the most efficient, most convenient, options. Our bodies are designed for it. They live in a colony with their families right up until 30 seconds before death. . Cooking meat on the other hand removes lots of water and reacts the fats and proteins in the meat to change how they taste. Sorry for the long post. I'm a meat-eater, but there's something i notice about other meat-eaters when they discuss veganism that i find interesting. often merino sheep, which aren’t good to eat). some blood types tend to do better when eating meat. I want to it is wrong to eat meat You don't know that. Or vegans may be ok with eating roadkill. We have mass farming technology. I hated steak when I was young. standard western diet) Whereas veges and vegans, who eschew processed foods, are common enough (they have been seriously studied for a long time). For example, I know with technological advances I don't have to kill an animal for food or clothing, but I still like to eat a steak and do not find it morally wrong. I also only eat red meat rarely, my daily meat is always fish or chicken. Yes. You are not an arbiter of good or evil if you eat meat: it is hypocrisy that is the true evil. That's your choice. While I think eating meat isn't ethically wrong, I do think animal farms should be abolished. Groups of people this view does not apply to: People who need to eat meat for health (i. If it's legal to kill (not endangered etc) then it's free game IMO. But in case of a deer, you are violating what vegans believe to be a "right of bodily autonomy and a right to life". Eating processed meat increases your risk of bowel and stomach cancer. Honestly, I've had to just forget I'm eating an animal but that doesn't really work. The remaining 75% of people will drastically cut back on meat & dairy - those 75% will view meat & dairy like tobacco by 2030. Yeah, this makes sense to me. I would not eat dog meat, but there are people who don’t eat cowsand I do. In the Pali discourses, there is not much weight given (if at all) to the results of actions that are several steps removed from the doer. He believed morals came from society so we focused on that claim. The former is wrong for many reasons. Ever! I have recently stumbled across a thread that discussed why Bestiality is considered ethically bad, while eating meat is considered ethically okay. Think of the 'natural' process of eating meat compared with the actual process that you go about doing it. For example lab grown meat. About canines: Our eating movements aren't typical of meat eaters. The Reddit Because of this, I raise my own meat rabbits. Therefore I would argue that factory farming is morally wrong, and therefore (with current technology) eating meat is inherently morally wrong. Related Reddit Ask Online community Social media Mobile app Meta/Reddit Website Information & communications technology Technology forward back. And that applies to the animals killed in the process of plant agriculture as well. I think that if eating meat is not necessary for your survival, then any pleasure you get from eating meat is irrelevant and should not be taken into account. Individuals who promote meat consumption do so for a number of reasons, such as health, cultural traditions, religious beliefs, and scientific arg Similarly to smokers, car drivers, and other common behaviors which can be detested for valid reasons, meat-eating does not cause Meat production is highly inefficient – this is particularly true when it comes to red meat. I focus our meals mostly on veggies, salads, whole grains, and the occasional servings of meat for my husband and myself. I think a more practical goal is a reduction in meat eating and increase in free range / organic animal rearing rather than elimination of all domestic animals. They cuddle and groom each other. This means that in situations where we would die if we don't eat meat, that we should kill and eat animals, or that it at least isn't wrong to do so. I didn't deny that. Lessening your meat consumption is better than not lessening it at all, it doesn't have to be black and white! You can eat horse meat. I always use a meat thermometer because you cannot tell if the meat has been brought to proper temps by just looking at it. some blood types feel better when eating dairy. We chew our food using our molars rather than swallowing chunks Canines are far from exclusive to meat eaters. It is also sometimes of the most expensive form of eating beef. I was chatting to a mate of mine about if eating people who have already died is morally wrong/right/amoral. It's not karmically unskilful in itself, however, and won't lead to rebirth in the lower realms. I’ve raised plenty of food animals that had full, happy, healthy lives. Freegan meat, overpopulated or invasive animals, many others. I haven't noticed a huge improvement in health eating meat so I'm contemplating trying vegetarianism or veganism again. If your 'personal' choice involves a victim, it's not a personal choice. Maybe down the road if they totally prove it's a healthy food I will add red meat back in in a slightly larger quantity, if it turns out they're right, I'll just keep it the same. It's not a moral argument, it's a result of evolution. The main issue I have with eating horses and dogs is that these animals are raised as companions or workers for people. It makes no sense. Serving as the official companion to VCJ, here we address the challenges that activists face within the animal rights movement. I realize it may be a bit tricky, but I really really want my guilt-free lamb roast. Apparently the risk is normally very low. i will one day be eaten by other animals, as is the norm for all forms of animal life. Meat is often oversalted (bad for heart) or grilled (carcinogenic) (or preserved, but you dont seem worried about that). beef and big AG are major contributors to the destruction of the environment. Meat farms are definitely in areas that could be arable farms, but there is a lot of money in lamb here (especially since a lot of lamb and beef farms have been converting to dairy, reducing the competition View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Ever. food combining is of the utmost importance in order to eat complete protein in a meal. There's the so-called 'triple clean' rule: . Sort by: cat_of_Yahoo • In my religion, it's not morally wrong. Yesterday I seasoned and cooked chicken thighs and drumsticks for dinner. While you can cook with soybeans, if you are going to eat soy in its natural form, it is usually consumed as edamame. You'd be wrong to say that we eat meat solely for comfort, we eat meat to obtain essential sustenance, just like every other living thing on the planet. " Source: Hindu husband's caste ate meat, so did eat eggs but never beef. The reason they're so preachy is that for them, not eating meat is a part of their moral identity. Make a stance, and stand The fact that you eat beef and pork isn't a moral justification. If you live somewhere other than a 3rd world country, it is completely possible to sustain society without eating meat. We’re really the only ones who have a The sheep farms on the more rugged land here in NZ are more wool than meat farms (e. ” On the “no it’s not ethical” side, people like Peter Singer argue that consciousness is a spectrum, not a black-and-white thing. I do know there are spiritual levels you won't be able to reach if you eat meat. Diet for Small Planet was my inspiration though, as well as slaughterhouse However, I also understand that for other cultures, it is horrifying to see us eat beef or pork. It's not a case of some waste being unavoidable or people need to serve smaller portions. It's safer and tastier. There are also more human centric approaches that focus on the environment or pandemic prevention. For vegetarians, there are either explicit or implicit philosophical values being acted on all the time (eating meat is wrong, or eating meat is unsustainable). I enjoy meat, I love meat, as much as I hate vegans, I have never ate dog meat but people for some reason hate on chinese for eating dog meat. g. I'm not saying humans didn't eat meat or crave it, but many pro meat eaters claim it was some sort of abundant food that all humans had everyday. Eating raw soybeans can cause some health related issues and there for most soy products are processed and marketed as things like tofu and meat alternatives. I eat meat because I am an omnivore. 41K subscribers in the DebateAVegan community. Or then I would agree with you that over-eating is a smaller problem than meat eating. We’ll explore details would you consider it moral to eat meat if the animal did not suffer? Would you consider it moral to kill a human if it did not suffer and the death was instantaneous? That's an easy one. Ultimately, you're ending the life of a sentient being without their consent by eating meat. I say that there are three instances in which meat should not be eaten: when it is seen, heard, or suspected that the There really really nothing bad about eating dog meat. People who practice traditional lifestyles and diets that are reliant on meat consumption for survival (i. major crops like barley , wheat , rice , maize are obtained by straight up cutting plants . If you find it wrong to kill animals, eating meat should be morally wrong. 40K subscribers in the DebateAVegan community. e. Whereas obviously, vegetarians and vegans are making what is usually a moral choice about eating meat. 🥩 🍔 ? Share Add a Comment. Unless you're vegan you already consume and wear things that require "subjugation and denial of autonomy" of animals. It's not categorically. Most people will agree that 1- Hurting or abusing animals unnecessarily is wrong 2- Most people in the developed world don't need to eat meat to be healthy Get the Reddit app Scan this is eating animal meat morally wrong . Therefore you have contributed to a longer cycle of death if you eat a dog. If you really like eating meat, donate $500 to a malaria While some vegans say eating meat is unnatural for humans (note, humans are not cheetahs), most vegans recognise that eating meat is natural. Meat eating is part of the natural cycle. Now, that is easier said than done because in my area we keep free-range chickens. But many, many things we do regularly without much thought are similarly immoral. The body of an animal is being put to much better use nourishing another life than it is rotting in the ground. i can see the stand or argument you want to address, which is how said animals are treated. I couldn’t even sit with meat eaters on the same table in my younger age. Edit: A The people who ate the most red meat (about 5 ounces a day or more) were about a third more likely to develop colon cancer than those who ate the least red meat (less than an ounce a day on average). It’s a Tu Quoque fallacy, a type of ad hominem, that you’re engaging in- people can absolutely engage in a behavior and issue a statement that goes against their own No it is not objectively wrong to eat meat, meat is a food source. I don’t think it’s morally wrong, I think if someone is eating dog meat it’s probably because that’s the option they have. This is where I'm conflicted on the morality of eating meat since we all as humans do kill animals in some way. i am not special in this regard. Once the creature is caught, it is killed and cooked over some sort of a fire. I could see if you earned the hamburger by wrestling the cow to the ground and then beating it to death with your bare hands. I won’t tell you not to eat beef or pork, or so many other gentle creatures, that’s your choice. Typically vegans eat a mix of different protein sources, although beans are the ones we use most often. But since it affects other beings (the animals for which's slaughtering you provide a financial incentive) it's not a purely personal decision and is subject to moral evaluation. I don't think that I should only eat meat, and I don't think eating meat is a good thing. If everyone on earth stops eating meat, the meat industry will also stop producing. Most of the time, though, it seems "manly" cuts of meat are just products someone has gone to the store to buy and then maybe they cook it themselves. I don’t think that eating meat is wrong, what puts me off is the industry and how animals are farmed Funnily if horses or dogs etc were treat like this there would be outrage. Get the Reddit app Scan this There is nothing wrong with eating horse meat . eating meat) poses an ethical problem, then an alternative which satisfies the benefits of eating meat, but does away with its ethical downsides, is preferable. Or (them eating meat, being domesticated, there might be logical reasons as to why eating dogs isn’t sustainable for the long term but it isnt wrong to eat them in general Eating meat is prohibited in Hinduism OR a brahman never eats meat OR Hinduism promotes vegetarian diet OR the one who eats meat is not a true Hindu So there is nothing wrong in eating non veg or veg. A person should not be criticized for his choice of food. Qualifiers: There are two caveats to my argument: one is lack of necessity at least in the west and the other is inescapable requirement of meat coming from a once living being with current technology . Meat eaters of Reddit, why is ok to have millions of cows slaughtered, but chinese eating dogs or Europeans eating horses is wrong? It is not wrong, Eating meat is not wrong. You are paying for an animal to be "The World Health Organization has classified processed meats including ham, bacon, salami and frankfurts as a Group 1 carcinogen (known to cause cancer) which means that there's strong evidence that processed meats cause cancer. those are some good reasons to eat meat, but doesn't justify the meat industry if people buy meat, its gonna be out of stock sooner, that will result in the meat industry producing more and therefore you actually contributed to the killing of these animals. Here again we see that monks ate meat and the Buddha did not criticize or disapprove of it. Some traditions completely forbid meat eating and see it as sinful, while other traditions allow it to different extents, but even those that allowed meat eating never sanctioned it completely without any restrictions. Red meat also contains high levels of cholesterol and carnitine (which can cause cardiometabolic problems). I mean exactly what I said. The real issue is one of product labeling. Consuming greater amounts of I also don't think there are any compelling objections to arguments that eating meat is immoral. Hello, I’m a meat eater. There are other foods we can get As a non vegan, I don't see why eating meat is morally wrong. Since eating foods that are animal derived almost always means that (the suffering) I do not eat meat and try my best to avoid products that come from animals. So there you have it, my first ever CMV :) EDIT: Thank you all for the replies! That is my personal reason for believing that eating meat is wrong. ) can make Yes, generally I would agree with that - eating meat is only morally wrong insofar as your decision to eat meat contributes to the demand for meat or directly causes the death of an animal. I like eating meat too much. Unprocessed soy however offers a wealth of eating meat is within the norms of my culture and community. I found I drifted off topic quite a lot, but we circled back to a few good analogies. have vitamin deficiencies that can only reasonably be addressed by eating meat, other health conditions, etc. Unless there's something wrong with eating bananas, it's not clear that it's a moral question at all. If you’re defending the dogs, you Numbers - meat requires you to feed the animals you eat, so it may end up killing more animals than other things, because the animal eats more than it yields and you kill both the animals required for the feed and the animal for the meat itself. With the HUGE caveat, that in the US, food manufacturers can add celery powder/juice to meat and still call it "nitrate free" or "no nitrates added". I do find the milk Posted by u/sealy__ - No votes and 17 comments Today, they're all dropping dead of heart failure and liver failure by eight weeks. They "decorate" the colony by moving sticks and pinecones around. This obviously doesn't make much sense in todays world because there are plenty of unnatural things that are not bad or that are good for us. All food is clean, but it is wrong for a person to eat anything that causes someone else to stumble. And society as a whole, including laws in every country on earth, agrees with that. But a lot of people do not find unnecessary harm and killing of a cow, chicken, pig, or fish wrong. Every now and then article pops up about how some people in a foreign culture eat horse meat, or you'll see someone freak out over a horse being killed. Finally a single cow can feed dozens of humans. Yes it is But saying that it’s wrong and immoral to eat meat is just too absolutist. Others say eating meat is unethical, since it harms animals. To me, meat isn't food. Eating meat is same as eating plants . Everything has to die, and everything that we ingest for food comes from something that was living. I think it’s ethical for the same reason it’s ethical for other species of omnivores to eat meat. You can eat dog meat, too. Shiva is detached from everything. In this case, I don’t think it is useful to condemn every meat eater as a bad person, even though their actions contribute to immense suffering. But please don’t eat dogs. If horse meat can get into meat that is supposed to be beef, who knows what else can. “Processed meats” are only carcinogenic when nitrates, nitrites, or various other chemicals are added AFAIK, Yes. Mostly vegan but I don’t want to be labelled as such. The problem is most meat eaters, in well off countries, also eat significant processed an inflammatory food (i. Meat-eaters seem have this overwhelming focus on the fact that supplements aren't natural and therefore a diet that requires someone to take a supplement cannot be a diet humans are meant to eat. They often contain high levels of sodium, which can contribute to negative health outcomes like high blood pressure, and may include additives and preservatives. You’re probably the same person who eats chicken and beef and stuff. (2) Eating meat causes unnecessary suffering. At the very least you could argue that eating meat that would be thrown out otherwise versus purchasing other food is acceptable (again, purely from a morality viewpoint, not health or environment). I am trying to start eating less meat, I find it dumb as fuck to know something is morally wrong and not at least trying to change it, it will eat you inside. however, I think a lot of Indian families now are relatively more at ease It's not intrinsically wrong to eat meat. From 2030, today’s young adults will be raising their children vegan, the unmovable pensioners of today will have passed away I think by 2035 meat & dairy will be illegal to sell in the first country. Orders three+ dishes every night and eats a few bites each and tosses the rest. Animals eat other animals. It's wrong to eat meat because we don't need it to survive AND because innocent animals suffer and die because of it. Members Online. hwjpe jliq ffnih akxwc cgcv ejn eemplq koopafg xhum wefsa