Ukraine join nato reddit. So the first option makes the most sense.
Ukraine join nato reddit Allowing them to join post crisis does the same, and in both cases we get a boat anchor of a nation in the alliance. Neither. I wouldn't trust the views of somebody on the question of "should Ukraine join NATO if they're from Russia. The most part of the nuclear underground shafts were situated in Ukraine and that is why most qualified and top of the class officers from all USSR were serving there. Once Ukraine has the strength they join nato when they are too powerful for Russia to do anything about it. So the first option makes the most sense. Biden/NATO want to put missiles and biolabs in Ukraine and Russia wants to protect its borders from that. By now, Russia dont have capabilities to fight with NATO, but if it conquers Ukraine, it will be much stonger. You join NATO when the times are good knowing that if they get bad, you're protected. FYI. Security guarantees that don't just say "we won't attack you". This fact also explains why so many people in Ukraine has family ties with Russia people and like Aken_Bosch said that is why people of Ukraine voted against Nato in 1992. A major one is that it just scored incredibly low on Ukrainians' radars. The statement that Ukraine would join Nato eventually was basically a threat to russia but simultaneously provided no military support to ukraine. Both NATO and Ukraine see Crimea as part of Ukraine. Kosovo and Serbia would join NATO together once their problems resolved. None of the other NATO members want to join a war with Russia, send their kids off to die and risk the threat of a nuclear war. Numerous people have stated NATO was never brought up as an issue after that and Russia even accepted NATO presence in former Soviet countries to support the Afghanistan conflict. Neither you, me or fcking Russia has absolutely no right to say anything about that, when independent countries are making their own independent NATO rejects any state at war or with internal military conflict. Yes so if Ukraine tries to take Crimea back that's not attacking unless you consider Crimea as part of Russia. NATO will not risk a war with Russia over territory that was stolen before a country joined. Check his profile. r/ukraine: HERE УКРАЇНА TAKES CENTER STAGE — The purpose of r/Ukraine is to amplify Ukrainian voices. The crux is that if Ukraine was in NATO, all of NATO would be bound to defend it from attack (by Putin). Due to the DPR/LPR operating in Ukraine, they were ineligible to join even before the invasion. If you're already in a conflict, too bad, NATO won't accept you. Austria wouldnt join NATO because they need to be neutral. I m hundred percent sure that Georgia Azerbaijan and Armenia would join NATO in the case of Russian defeat in Ukraine. Right now, it's impossible to provide a road map to ukrainian membership because the result of the war is unknown. So, if Putin doesn't attack now or receive a commitment than Ukraine won't join nato, he can't later without involving NATO militarily. Allowing them to join nato now invites a limited but multinational war. Obviously Ukraine wouldn’t want to join NATO if Russia wasn’t making them fearful for their sovereignty, but a nuclear defense tr Hungary is less corrupt and significantly more developed than Ukraine and currently has soldiers risking their lives for a NATO mission and Türkiye is arguably one of the 4 most important NATO members. Edit - Of course you're Russian. Let’s start by recalling that the North Atlantic Treaty Jul 12, 2023 · As Western leaders met with top Ukrainian officials at a pivotal NATO summit this week, Ukraine was worried about the ghosts of summits past that may have helped pave the way to the war it’s Sep 11, 2023 · A February 2023 poll showed 83% of the people surveyed said Ukraine should join NATO. Putin can sell Russia that Ukraine will not join NATO. Please dont kill me, I'm just genuinely trying to learn a bit more about the situation outside of major media outlets. Putin cant sell being defeated by the Ukraine, and will likely resort to any means necessary to force a victory, but he could sell a defeat if the entirety of NATO gangs up and "bullies" him out of Ukraine. We are at war, so content is tightly moderated … Like, if Ukraine joined NATO now, every NATO member would have to declare war on Russia. NATO should keep expanding because there are independent countries where majority of the population wants to join NATO and democratically elected government does it's best to achieve this goal. Among the reasons not to allow Ukraine to join is the possibility that accepting Ukraine into NATO would have the opposite effect. If the only thing standing between Ukraine’s membership in NATO was a few thousand separatists with old AKs, that is far too tenuous of a situation to rest your national security on Ukraine cannot join NATO now as NATO has a clause that countries with territorial issues cannot join, they have to resolve them first. The following is a copy of the original post to record the post as it was originally written. All cost and no benefit The war ends without Ukraine joining nato. Option 2 is getting less and less likely, the west isn’t going to want to fund this war forever. They need a unanimous vote from all NATO members to join and Hungary has been blocking it since 2018 But if it were to happen in the future, those areas would be lost to Russia. Instead of being a deterrent, it could provoke a full scale conflict or deepened hostilities with Russia. Ukraine in NATO died as a topic in 2008, after NATO rejected Ukraine's application and Obama's reset of Russian relations after Bush. Ukraine doesn’t join NATO. Ukraine reclaims all lost territory, winning the war, and then joins NATO. I have no doubt that Ukraine will win Yup, they wont just stop at ukraine, they want the continent and i just recently heard some state TV people over there were shouting they wanted to take over the world. It would be a defensive move. From what I gather, the threats from Russia seem to be real, and Ukraine has stated it wants to join NATO, and the current NATO countries want Ukraine to join if im not mistaken. " That would be like asking my opinion on "should the Ukraine join the Warsaw Pact. But we don't need every single NATO country to declare war in order to do that. Ukraine was never even close to accession into NATO due to the deeply ingrained Soviet era facets of it's economy amongst other things. Simply put, if Ukraine joins NATO, Russia is now technically occupying NATO territory. But "country XY will defend Ukraine in the case of an invasion or imminent invasion with all the military strength required". Ukraine is one of the most corrupt nations in the world and fails virtually every litmus test for a nato alliance membership. I think Ukraine will ultimately be made a NATO member. However, let’s assume the hypothetical, that Ukraine has does not have territorial issues and joins NATO. So Ukraine has to do is win and the NATO powers that be to uphold their end of the bargain. I think they deserve autonomy and their borders should be expected, but that’s kinda a huge slap in the face to Russia. The current conflict in Ukraine isn't primarily about NATO expansion, because Ukraine was not a member of NATO at the time of the 2022 invasion, or in imminent danger of Keeping both in mind - as for why Ukraine didn't aspire to join NATO in the 1990s through 2002, during the period when countries like Poland, the Baltics, or the Czech Republic did have stated policies to join the alliance, there are a few factors in play. 0. Of course Ukraine doesn’t like that, but that doesn’t really matter if we’re being pragmatic. By June 2023, the EU’s leaders had determined that Ukraine had met two of seven conditions required for the country to begin membership talks. This of course doesn't mean that Putin's murder of civilians is justified, just that the US shouldn't have disregarded Russia's complaints against the expansion of NATO. Lets say however, for whatever reason, Ukraine is all of a sudden allowed into NATO and before anyone can react it within a day joins NATO. It is stupid to fight much stronger enemy in the future when you have chance to stop him now, and only way to do it is to accept Ukraine in NATO. Ukraine is already winning thankfully and we will keep supporting them until victory is acheived Ukraine is not joining NATO. NATO is a defensive organization. At this point, having Ukraine join NATO would be the safest bet. So keep that in mind when biden says "we must defend the member state of nato", cuz Ukraine doesn't belong to nato. " Seems pretty clear that joining NATO is something that could only be discussed once Russia and Ukraine have reached a peace deal and I can't imagine Russia agreeing to any deal that would allow them to join NATO. Play the long game. And Ukraine, with NATO’s backing, was trying to end the conflict, partially to restore their territorial integrity and partially to be eligible for NATO membership. However Ukraine can get NATO like security guarantees without calling it NATO. Ukraine isn't part of NATO cuz they didn't met the requirements to join. Then all ukrainian resources including people will be used against NATO. Meanwhile Ukraine didn't want to join NATO before the war(s) and now the only reason they stand a chance is because of massive foreign aid. Officially inside NATO, Ukraine is actually now able to force other members to declare war on Russia whenever it wants due to the occupation of Crimea. Dec 17, 2024 · Ukraine stepped up its efforts to join NATO after Russia invaded last year, arguing that the security assurances given by Moscow, Washington and London when it relinquished its nuclear Mar 5, 2024 · That said, bringing Ukraine into NATO now is a bad idea that will prolong the war and leave Kyiv in an even worse position over time. The west helps Ukraine become South Korea 2. Time is on Ukraines side at this point. Why tf would we want to do that And to be clear I want Ukraine to win. That being said, there's going to be a strong interest in Ukraine joining NATO if the current war is resolved decisively in their favor. ynpq dwhw sky uvoqni tppqm uwvlzuwy mgeqg ichr slgh sqiso